Story Review

haowjy/creative-writing-skills/skills/story-review

by haowjy254d4bb9b3b2e50a47def955b6461c06057eedaeNo licenseListed Oct 9, 2026Updated Oct 9, 2026

Review work after prose exists: editorial review, craft critique, continuity/voice review, copyediting, proofreading, and synthesis of reader-sim signal. Load when diagnosing a draft rather than rewriting it.

Includes scriptsWriting & Content
AI-generated overview

Reviews existing prose at editorial, developmental, line, copyedit and proofreading levels, plus adversarial craft critique.

What it does
This skill performs analytical diagnosis of prose that already exists, rather than rewriting it. It routes the work to one of five edit levels, from holistic editorial review down to a final proofreading pass, and each level has its own resource file with method and checklist. It also supports adversarial craft critique across structure, character, voice, prose and continuity, and can synthesize reader-sim signal alongside analytical critique. It ships an executable script under the prose-critique resources.
When to use it
Use it when a draft needs to be diagnosed rather than rewritten, such as deciding what kind of revision a manuscript needs and in what order. It fits structural, voice, continuity, copyediting and proofreading passes on existing prose. Keep it separate from a felt first-time reader experience task, which the skill says belongs to reader-sim.
Requirements
An agent that can read the bundled markdown resources and run the shipped script at resources/prose-critique/analyze.py. No credentials or network access are stated.

Story Review

Analytical review of existing prose. This skill is for diagnosis, not rewriting. Keep /reader-sim separate when the task needs a felt first-time reader experience rather than analytical critique.

Choose the review level before reading. Start big before small unless the caller explicitly asks for a late-stage pass. The edit levels move from structural to surface, and each assumes the levels above it are stable:

  • Editorial review — holistic third-party book-editor pass. What kind of revision does this draft need, and in what order?
  • Developmental edit — structure, promise, causality, pacing, character arc. Is the draft the right shape?
  • Line edit — voice, rhythm, clarity, texture. Does the prose move well?
  • Copyedit — grammar, usage, punctuation, consistency. Is it correct?
  • Proofreading — final surface pass. What slipped through?

Each level has a dedicated resource with method and checklist:

  • resources/editorial-review.md
  • resources/developmental-edit.md
  • resources/line-edit.md
  • resources/copyedit.md
  • resources/proofreading.md

For adversarial craft critique (as opposed to editorial review), load:

  • resources/prose-critique.md — methodology and focus-area routing.
  • resources/prose-critique/ — deep resources per focus area (structure, character, voice, prose, continuity).

When review incorporates reader-sim data:

  • resources/reader-sim-signal.md — how to interpret and synthesize reader-sim output alongside analytical critique.

Source and attribution

Source:haowjy/creative-writing-skillsinskills/story-reviewat commit254d4bb

License: No license

Content belongs to its original authors. SourceWeft indexes it from a public repository.

Report or request removal

More from haowjy/creative-writing-skills

Writing Staffing

haowjy

Reference for staffing writing workflows: which extra skills to attach, what to reference in spawn prompts, and when to fan out.

AI & AgentsOct 9, 2026

Writing Principles

haowjy

What fiction readers want (reader reward channels) and the specific ways LLM training damages them. Load when drafting prose, critiquing, or diagnosing why a passage feels flat.

Awaiting classificationOct 9, 2026

Story Planning

haowjy

Plans stories before drafting: creative direction, brainstorming, outlining and story architecture.

Writing & ContentOct 9, 2026

Story Memory

haowjy

Creative-writing domain knowledge for durable story state. Load when preserving or retrieving project memory — fact extraction, context scoping, reference writing, artifact layout, and issue tracking. If you are a knowledge agent such as kb-lead, load this for the fiction-specific categories and conventions your general methodology doesn't cover.

Awaiting classificationOct 9, 2026

Reader Sim

haowjy

Read as a specified first-time reader persona and report the felt experience. Use for skill-only workflows when a draft needs persona-bound reader-response signal instead of analytical critique.

Awaiting classificationOct 9, 2026

Creative Writing Modes

haowjy

Adds a creative-writing layer for drafting, revising, bridging, varying, or polishing prose.

Writing & ContentOct 9, 2026

More in Writing & Content

Doc Coauthoring

anthropics

Featured

Guides users through a three-stage workflow to co-author documentation, proposals, specs and decision docs.

Writing & Content180Kupdated today

Writing Guidelines

vercel-labs

Featured

Reviews documentation and prose against fetched Writing Guidelines and reports style findings.

Writing & Content32Kupdated 5 weeks ago

Job Post Builder

anthropics

Featured

Builds a hiring packet — job post, interview guide with rubrics, and offer letter template — from a role brief.

Writing & Content27Kupdated today

Write Spec

anthropics

Featured

Turns a feature idea or problem statement into a structured PRD with goals, user stories, requirements and metrics.

Writing & Content27Kupdated today

Draft Content

anthropics

Featured

Drafts marketing content such as blog posts, social posts, newsletters, landing pages, press releases and case studies.

Writing & Content27Kupdated today

Brand Voice Enforcement

anthropics

Featured

Applies existing brand voice guidelines to sales and marketing content, then explains the brand choices made.

Writing & Content27Kupdated today